A new report done by the Energy Futures Institute, a non-profit which works to lower carbon emissions, states that government-mandated electric vehicle sales could destabilize markets, reduce consumer choice, drive up costs and benefit car companies like Tesla. While this report looked at British Columbia and Canada, it is entirely possible that the case would be the same for the U.S. We have seen electric car mandates in some states such as California. In the future, Californians will be unable to purchase a gas powered vehicle if the model is 2035 or later. Bans like this go against market fundamentals as in the year 2035 we will have no idea what the demand for gas powered vehicles will be. Furthermore, this ban lessens consumer choice. Finally, we do not know if we will have the infrastructure to support more electric cars. Overall, while climate change is unquestionably an existential threat, more flexible policies are needed.
2 comments:
The report from the Energy Futures Institute raises some valid concerns about government-mandated electric vehicle (EV) sales and their potential consequences, especially regarding market instability, consumer choice, and costs. The infrastructure challenge is an example of market instability, consumer choice, and costs. For example, the infrastructure challenge is a significant issue in pushing EV adoption is the current lack of charging infrastructure, particularly in rural or less densely populated areas. For a broad transition to electric vehicles to be successful, significant investment is needed in charging stations, battery technology, and grid capacity. In summary, the argument against a blanket mandate for electric vehicles is rooted in concerns about market forces, consumer choice, infrastructure readiness, and the unintended benefits it may provide to established companies. A balanced, flexible approach is essential to ensure that the shift to electric vehicles is both sustainable and beneficial for all stakeholders.
I am not sure if limiting the market choice is the solution. I think electric vehicles are almost inevitable at this point but I think the market can solve this not through regulation but by innovation and increased infrastructure that follows demand. Cars are expensive and this big investments may take a while for some families to transition over to.
Post a Comment